2025 Remodeling Impact Report: What Renovations Are REALLY Worth It?

In today’s real estate climate, it’s more important than ever to be smart about your home renovation dollars. Whether you're planning to sell or simply want to love your home more, not all upgrades are created equal—some bring major joy and strong resale value, while others fall flat. Thankfully, the 2025 Remodeling Impact Report from the National Association of Realtors gives us clear, data-driven answers.

In this episode of Selling Greenville, Stan McCune breaks down the top renovation projects based on homeowner satisfaction, resale value, Realtor recommendations, and more. If you're wondering what home updates are really worth it—especially here in the Upstate—this report offers powerful insights.

What the 2025 Remodeling Impact Report Reveals

Every year, the National Association of Realtors surveys homeowners and real estate professionals to better understand which remodeling projects bring the most satisfaction—and the best return on investment. This year's report provides a fascinating window into which upgrades actually pay off and why.

The Renovation Projects That Bring the Most Joy

The “Joy Score” is a 1–10 rating measuring how much happiness homeowners feel after a renovation. In 2025, three projects earned perfect 10s:

• Adding a Primary Bedroom SuiteThis one is big—especially when a bathroom is added to an existing bedroom. The convenience and privacy can be life-changing.

• Kitchen UpgradeIt’s no surprise kitchens bring joy. As one of the most used (and visible) spaces in a home, upgrades here often uplift the entire vibe.

• New RoofingThis one’s surprising. A roof might not seem joyful, but strong curb appeal and peace of mind make a big difference for many homeowners.

Lower joy scores included garage door installations and basement conversions—both of which may improve utility or value but don’t necessarily increase daily enjoyment.

Which Projects Offer the Best Return on Investment?

Not all renovations give you your money back. But according to the report, these ones come close—or even break even:

• New Steel Front Door – 100% Cost RecoveryA brand-new front door can drastically improve curb appeal and first impressions.

• Closet Renovation – 83% Cost RecoveryCustom closets are highly attractive to buyers and show that a home is well-organized.

• Fiberglass Front Door – 80% Cost RecoveryAgain, doors matter more than you might think.

• New Windows – 67-68% Cost RecoveryBoth vinyl and wood windows ranked high, with added energy efficiency and aesthetics driving value.

Interestingly, major kitchen renovations and bathroom upgrades fell around the 50–60% cost recovery mark—suggesting that bigger-ticket items don’t always give dollar-for-dollar returns unless they’re done strategically.

What Realtors Are Telling Sellers To Do Before Listing

When preparing to sell, these are the updates real estate agents recommend most often:

1. Paint the Entire Home (50%)A fresh coat of paint is inexpensive, easy, and instantly improves how a home shows.

2. Paint a Specific Room (41%)Targeting bold or outdated colors—like that Clemson-orange teenager’s room—can make a huge difference.

3. Replace Roofing (37%)With homeowner insurance policies tightening, a worn roof can kill a deal.

4. Upgrade the Kitchen (30%)Even minor improvements (new cabinet hardware, lighting, backsplash) can help.

5. Renovate the Bathroom (24%)Be strategic here—don’t over-renovate beyond your neighborhood or price point.

What Projects Are in High Demand?

According to the report, Realtors have seen increased buyer demand for:

• Kitchen upgrades (48%)

• New roofing (43%)

• Bathroom renovations (35%)

• Interior painting (32%)

• Full kitchen renovations (26%)

These trends underscore how today’s buyers are prioritizing turnkey homes with modern finishes—and how sellers should respond accordingly.

The Most Common Reasons People Remodel

Why do homeowners take on these projects in the first place?

• 27%: To upgrade worn surfaces or materials

• 19%: To improve energy efficiency

• 18%: Planning to sell within 2 years

• 18%: Just ready for a change

Only a small percentage cited resale value or organization as the primary motivator, proving that emotion and function often trump financial return when it comes to remodeling.

Financing: How People Are Paying for Renovations

Home improvement projects aren’t cheap, and most people don’t pay out of pocket. According to the data:

• 54% used a home equity loan or line of credit

• 29% paid with savings

• 10% used a credit card

• 3% received financial gifts (lucky them!)

This tells us that renovations are major investments for most homeowners—and that low-interest financing options remain the most popular method.

Who’s Doing the Work—and Who Regrets It

• 29% hired professionals for the entire job

• 24% DIY’d it

• 24% hired labor but bought materials

• 23% said they wish they had used a pro

That last number is telling. It’s a reminder that doing it yourself isn’t always cheaper if you have to fix mistakes later. Be honest about your skill level before diving into a renovation.

What’s the Emotional Impact?

• 46% had increased enjoyment after the project

• 55% felt a major sense of accomplishment

• 92% said they’d remodel more if cost wasn’t an issue

On the flip side, 16% reported decreased enjoyment. Whether due to poor workmanship, long delays, or misaligned expectations, it’s a cautionary tale: renovations need careful planning and the right team to truly deliver joy.

The Bottom Line

Before you tear out that bathroom or start shopping for granite, know what really adds value—and what doesn’t. Use this report as your guide and remember: a smart remodel starts with a smart plan.

Watch or Listen to the Selling Greenville Podcast

Subscribe to the Selling Greenville podcast for real-time insights, bold perspectives, and unfiltered takes on the Upstate housing scene. Whether you’re buying, selling, or simply watching the market unfold—this is where Greenville goes to stay informed.

Final Thoughts

Home remodeling is more than a financial investment—it’s an emotional one. The 2025 Remodeling Impact Report shows us that while certain upgrades (like front doors and paint) consistently deliver value and happiness, others need a more nuanced, case-by-case approach. If you're renovating for your own enjoyment, go for it—but if resale is your goal, talk to a local real estate expert first. A well-timed conversation can save you thousands and steer your project in the right direction.

Follow @StanMcCune for more data-driven insights, market trends, and expert strategies in real estate. Whether you're buying, selling, or investing, Stan McCune breaks down complex real estate topics into practical advice you can use to make smarter decisions in the Greenville market and beyond.

Ien Araneta

Journal & Podcast Editor | Selling Greenville