Buyer and Seller Strategies for a Shifting Market

Greenville’s real estate scene has officially entered a new chapter. Remember the whirlwind days when homes barely hit the market before vanishing? Yeah… those are over (for now). What we’re seeing instead is a slower, more thoughtful game—less speed dating, more chess.

This week’s Selling Greenville dives into what buyers and sellers can actually do in a shifting market. The advice? Don’t panic, don’t guess, and don’t fall for every headline screaming “crash.” The market isn’t collapsing—it’s just… evolving.

Greenville Real Estate Shifting Market Strategies

The focus keyword here—Greenville Real Estate Shifting Market Strategies—says it all. Change is in the air, but change doesn’t mean chaos. Whether you’re buying or selling, the real trick now is adjusting your mindset (and maybe your expectations) to match what’s really happening out there.

For Buyers: How to Play the Long Game

1. Ignore the doom and gloom. You know the type—people on social media predicting a “2008 repeat” every other week. (If they were right, they’d have been billionaires by now.) These “doomers” love scaring people with half-truths, cherry-picked charts, and dramatic thumbnails. But Greenville isn’t San Francisco or Boise.

Here, delinquency rates are sitting comfortably under 1%. That’s a record low. So no, the sky isn’t falling. The grass is still green in Greenville—pun intended.

2. Stop banking on a miracle rate drop. Mortgage rates are floating around the upper sixes, and while a small dip might happen later this year, it’s unlikely we’ll see a huge drop until late 2025. (Think of it as waiting for your favorite band to reunite—it’ll happen, just not when you want it to.)

The smart move? Don’t time the market. Time your life. If the numbers make sense, go for it.

3. Don’t get greedy with price drops. A seller drops the price, and suddenly everyone thinks it’s open season for lowball offers. But if a seller already cut $20K, odds are the new price is close to fair—and a good deal gets snatched fast.

It’s kind of like seeing a sale at your favorite store: if you overthink it, someone else buys your size.

4. Figure out what matters most to the seller. Not every seller is driven by dollars alone. Some care about timing, others want fewer repairs, and a few just want to sell to someone who feels like a good fit. (Yes, that’s a thing.)

A good agent will dig into what motivates the seller, because sometimes a small change in your offer—like flexible closing—can make all the difference.

5. Focus on the monthly payment, not the sticker shock. Here’s a secret: that $10,000 difference everyone obsesses over might only change your monthly payment by a few bucks. Buyers love round numbers, but your budget loves math. Focus on the payment you’ll actually live with, not the one that looks better in theory.

For Sellers: How to Stand Out (Without Losing Your Mind)

1. Always counter—even when the offer looks perfect. It’s tempting to accept the first strong offer that lands in your inbox, but a little back-and-forth gives you valuable insight. How buyers handle small negotiations usually tells you how they’ll handle big ones later—like inspection surprises or appraisal hiccups.

If they get huffy over $500, wait until they see the roof report.

2. Don’t overprice. Please. This can’t be said enough. Overpricing your home is like showing up to a party wearing a tux when everyone else is in jeans—it just doesn’t fit.

A few years ago, homes overpriced by $15,000 or more sold for about $12 less per square foot than properly priced ones. On a 3,000-square-foot home, that’s roughly $36,000 left on the table—just for aiming too high.

Price it right from the start, and the market rewards you. Price it wrong, and you’ll end up chasing buyers who have already moved on.

3. Fix what needs fixing—or price it in. If something’s broken, don’t pretend it isn’t. (Buyer's notice. They always notice.) Either handle the repairs before listing or adjust your price to reflect reality.

Trying to hide issues is like spraying air freshener in a car that’s on fire—it only works for a minute.

4. Don’t cut out buyer agents. Commissions are changing, yes, but eliminating buyer agent compensation entirely can backfire hard. Around 95% of buyers still want agent representation, and many can’t afford to pay their agent directly.

If you make it harder for them to buy your home, guess what? They won’t. Be smart—widen your buyer pool, not shrink it.

5. Be honest about your competition. Your competition isn’t last year’s sale down the street; it’s the other listings sitting live right now. Many sellers love to nitpick other homes (“Ours has a better floor plan!” or “That kitchen’s tiny!”), but buyers aren’t making emotional decisions—they’re comparing features and prices.

In a market with more inventory, you can’t charm your way into a higher offer. The market is brutally fair—it tells the truth whether we like it or not.

Watch Or Listen To The Selling Greenville Podcast

Subscribe to the Selling Greenville Podcast for real-time insights, bold perspectives, and unfiltered takes on the Upstate housing scene. Whether you’re buying, selling, or just watching the market unfold—this is where Greenville goes to stay informed.

Bottom Line

Greenville’s market isn’t broken—it’s just normal again. Buyers can breathe, sellers can plan, and both sides have to work a little smarter.

The key? Be flexible. Be realistic. And maybe keep your sense of humor handy, because in real estate, timing is everything (and patience is underrated).

At the end of the day, homes still sell, people still move, and Greenville still shines. The game hasn’t changed—just the pace.

Ien Araneta

Journal & Podcast Editor | Selling Greenville