Home Improvement Rip-Offs

Every homeowner wants to upgrade their space, live more comfortably, and, ideally, build value along the way. But some “upgrades” drain wallets without delivering what was promised. In this episode of Selling Greenville, the host lays out five all-too-common pitfalls that trip up Upstate owners—especially when slick sales pitches meet complex systems most people don’t specialize in.

What follows is a practical, Greenville-centric guide to the biggest traps, why they’re so persuasive, and how to navigate upgrades with eyes wide open.

The Biggest Home Improvement Rip-Offs

That phrase isn’t clickbait—it’s the theme. “Home Improvement Rip-Offs” captures a pattern: expensive changes pitched as must-dos, oversized “solutions” to small (or imaginary) problems, and upgrades that look good on a quote but don’t pencil out in real life. Here are the five offenders spotlighted in the episode.

1) Solar Panels: High Cost, Low Payoff (For Most)

For some, solar is a values decision. But viewed strictly by the numbers, the math often disappoints—especially in the Upstate.

• Leases are the worst offenders. Monthly lease payments + a still-existing power bill = modest savings at best. Then, when it’s time to sell, many owners discover they’re on the hook to pay off the lease at closing—sometimes in the tens of thousands—after saving maybe a few bucks a month.

• Buying the system is expensive. The episode cites homeowners paying $30K–$40K+ to purchase panels. Even optimistic payback tales stretch across years (think 8–12+), and life happens—people move long before they break even.

• Real-world headaches. Panels on the roof complicate insurance claims; if hail damages shingles, insurers typically won’t remove panels for you. That removal becomes the owner’s problem and cost.

• Aesthetic reality. Many buyers simply don’t like the look of panels on the front of a home—another potential resale friction point.

Bottom line from the episode: if someone insists on going solar, don’t lease, and go in with realistic savings expectations over a long time horizon. Most households are better off tackling efficiency—smart controls, modern appliances—before throwing money at panels.

2) Mold Remediation: When Fear Becomes a Business Plan

Mold exists everywhere—inside, outside, in every home. That’s the context many “inspect, test, and fix” outfits omit while they build a revenue stream from worry.

• The common playbook: A “mold expert” tests the home (they’ll always find mold), then funnels the owner to their own remediation division or a friendly firm sharing referral fees.

• What actually matters: In typical situations, real issues show up in obvious ways—visible growth where moisture is present. Two simple numbers act as guardrails: indoor humidity under ~60% and crawlspace moisture under ~20%. When those are in range, and a good home inspection (plus the standard CL-100 termite & moisture check) doesn’t flag anything, the danger scenario most people fear usually isn’t there.

• Health changes are a clue. If someone in the home develops new, persistent issues (asthma, specific allergies), then air quality testing makes sense—and extra caution is warranted.

The point isn’t to ignore mold; it’s to avoid paying for problems invented by the test. Solve moisture sources, fix leaks promptly, replace affected materials where needed, and keep humidity in check. Most of the time, that’s the whole play.

3) Roofing: Good Upsells vs. Bad Ones

Roofs wear out. Replacing them isn’t optional—but how you replace them matters.

The smart upgrade:

• Architectural (30-year) shingles instead of 20-year three-tab. The durability and performance difference is huge; this is the one upsell the episode endorses without hesitation.

Upsells to scrutinize:

• Ice & water shield across the entire roof. In South Carolina, that’s generally unnecessary. Roofing felt typically does the job here; limited ice & water use (like in valleys) can make sense, but blanketing an upstate roof with it is, at best, overkill.

• Covering old shingles with new shingles or metal. It sounds thrifty—and some roofers push it—but it’s a bad idea. You’re not replacing the underlayment (felt) that actually keeps water out, and you’re stacking weight on a structure never designed for multiple layers. That’s a structural risk, not a feature.

What to do instead: Get multiple quotes from reputable companies. Don’t share quotes between bidders—let each roofer diagnose and price independently so you can spot padding and scare tactics.

4) Crawl Space Encapsulation: The Thousand-Dollar “Solution” You Probably Don’t Need

Crawl spaces in the Upstate should have a vapor barrier—that’s basic. When moisture is elevated, there are often simple fixes: improve drainage, add a dehumidifier, install a sump pump, or repair specific issues.

What too many companies sell instead is full crawl space encapsulation—a multi-thousand-dollar project marketed as the only way. According to the episode, 99% of crawl spaces do not need it. (The host goes so far as to suggest the truly necessary cases are a tiny fraction of homes.) If someone pushes encapsulation:

• Get a second opinion—ideally from a company that doesn’t only sell encapsulations.

• Ask for stepwise options with moisture readings to match. If simpler measures get numbers in range, done is better (and cheaper) than “comprehensive.”

5) Chimney Repairs: The Upsell That Never Ends

Fireplaces feel cozy until the estimate lands. The episode recounts a “simple” sweep and minor repair request that turned into a $5,000 proposal—an all-too-common script:

• Most people aren’t chimney experts. That knowledge gap invites aggressive upselling on top of routine sweeping and obvious fixes.

• Your best defense: Collect several quotes, and then talk to homeowners who frequently burn wood. Experienced users tend to know which repairs are essential vs. gilding the lily.

Fire and smoke safety are non-negotiable. But so is declining work that feels padded. Use trusted referrals, stack estimates, and be suspicious of one-visit sky-high “must replace everything” pitches.

Red Flags & Reality Checks (Across All Five)

The episode’s examples share a pattern. Keep these guardrails in mind before you sign:

• “Only we can fix this.” If a company’s entire business model solves only one problem (and it’s always your problem), get another opinion.

• Testing tied to selling. When the same outfit tests, diagnoses, and performs expensive work, incentives aren’t aligned.

• Fear-first sales. Words like “urgent,” “dangerous,” or “catastrophic failure” can be real—but they’re also easy buttons for upsells. Ask for readings, photos, and specifics tied to standards (humidity %, moisture %, material damage, etc.).

• No step-down options. Honest pros provide tiered paths—from simplest/cheapest fixes to comprehensive—so you can decide.

Quick Reference: Smarter Moves the Episode Endorses

• Choose architectural shingles over three-tab when roofing.

• Fix leaks and visible damage first; keep humidity under ~60% inside, crawlspace moisture under ~20%.

• Be wary of solar leases; buying panels still takes many years to break even, and complications can snowball when selling or filing roof claims.

• Before crawl space encapsulation, try a vapor barrier, dehumidifier, and drainage.

• For chimneys, multiple quotes and advice from experienced wood-burners beat one oversized bid.

Watch Or Listen To The Selling Greenville Podcast

Subscribe to the Selling Greenville podcast for real-time insights, bold perspectives, and unfiltered takes on the Upstate housing scene. Whether you’re buying, selling, or simply watching the market unfold—this is where Greenville goes to stay informed.

Bottom Line

Upgrades should improve comfort, safety, and value—not bankroll bloated scopes and shiny sales decks. The episode’s five Home Improvement Rip-Offs—solar leases (and many purchases), mold “find it anywhere” remediation, unnecessary roofing extras and overlay installs, crawl space encapsulations sold as cure-alls, and chimney repair upsells—share one theme: overpaying for problems you don’t have, or oversolving the ones you do.

The antidote is simple and repeatable: verify moisture and humidity numbers, start with basic fixes, insist on independent quotes, and separate testing from selling whenever possible. When big-ticket work is truly needed, you’ll still end up there—just without paying for the parts that aren’t.

Ien Araneta

Journal & Podcast Editor | Selling Greenville