Using Section 8 Rentals as a Rent Deflation Hedge

Before diving into data, strategy, or market angles, it helps to understand why this topic even matters right now. Investor questions about Greenville’s Section 8 program have been piling up, and many of them come from pure confusion—confusion about how vouchers work, how rent amounts are set, and whether the program is steady or unpredictable. And with one large Simpsonville multifamily portfolio hitting the market, the chatter has only grown louder.

At its core, this conversation is about stability. (A rare word in real estate, right?) It’s also about misunderstanding—because a whole lot of investors think they know how Section 8 rentals operate, but what they “know” often has very little to do with reality.

And that’s where this breakdown comes in.

Section 8 Rentals as a Rent Deflation Hedge

The heart of the discussion centers on why Section 8 rentals behave differently from the private-pay market—and why that difference can act as a hedge when rents soften elsewhere. In Greenville, the Section 8 program operates with persistent demand, predictable payments, and a shortage of approved housing, which creates a unique environment (the “rare unicorn” of rental real estate).

The transcript makes one theme clear: while private rents can fall during slow cycles, Section 8 rents almost never do. They consistently rise year over year, even in broader market downturns. That alone puts Section 8 rentals in a category of their own, and for many investors, that stability becomes the safety net when the rest of the rental market feels shaky.

A Program Built for Renters With Nowhere Else to Go

The Section 8 conversation begins with context: who the program serves. Most voucher holders in Greenville are single parents with multiple children, though homeless veterans also qualify. Eligibility isn’t guesswork—the Housing Authority evaluates income, criminal background, family size, and need before issuing vouchers tied to specific bedroom counts and rent caps.

But even with a voucher in hand, renters face a harsh reality: only a tiny slice of Greenville landlords accept Section 8. That creates the imbalance the transcript emphasizes—massive demand, tiny supply, and renters who often struggle for months to find even one qualifying home. (Think musical chairs, but with thousands of players and only a handful of chairs.)

The Rent Numbers Most Investors Don’t Expect

One of the biggest misconceptions the transcript addresses is rent amount.

Most assume Section 8 always pays below-market rates.

Reality: in Greenville, the Housing Authority often approves rents that exceed private market rent for similar units due to limited supply. The transcript includes examples where switching a unit from private pay to Section 8 produced immediate rent jumps—sometimes hundreds per month.

And here’s the kicker: Across a decade of experience referenced in the transcript, Section 8 rents never decreased. Not once.

That’s where the entire “rent deflation hedge” idea comes from—because private market rents can absolutely dip when the economy softens, stimulus dries up, or supply temporarily surges (looking at you, 2020–2021). But Section 8 rates move in one direction only: up. (Unlike your favorite restaurant, which keeps shrinking the portion size.)

Why Some Investors Still Hesitate

Even with the stability, many landlords still avoid Section 8—and the transcript breaks their objections into two categories:

1. “Section 8 tenants damage property.”

This shows up constantly, but it’s almost always tied to weak screening, not the program. Section 8 does not replace the landlord’s responsibility to vet tenants. Screening still matters—arguably more than ever. (You wouldn't hire someone because their résumé “seems fine,” right?)

2. Inspections can be annoying.

This one is fair. Section 8 inspections aren’t cosmetic but compliance-based, and some requirements can feel overly technical or wildly inconsistent (“different inspector, different mood, different rules”). But irritating doesn’t mean unpredictable—just bureaucratic. And bureaucracy, at least, is consistent in its inconsistency. (Cue the collective landlord sigh.)

The Not-So-Unpredictable Reality

A major moment in the transcript is when an investor walks away from an 11-unit opportunity due to fears that the Section 8 program is “too unpredictable.”

But the transcript’s entire point is that this belief is backward.

In the years covered:

• Section 8 rents never dropped.

• Annual rent increases were common.

• Payments were punctual and deposited automatically every month.

• Market volatility, recessions, and shifting private pay dynamics didn’t meaningfully affect voucher amounts.

If anything, the private-pay rental market has proven far more volatile—responding to interest rates, inflation, stimulus periods, recessions, and tenant affordability challenges. Section 8 rentals, on the other hand, run on need, shortage, and structured government formulas.

It’s not glamorous, but it is steady.

The Flip Side: Not Financial Advice (But a Clear Pattern)

The transcript stays firm on this point: choosing to pursue Section 8 rentals should always be discussed with a financial advisor. It’s not a universal fit, and portfolio balance matters.

But the data and lived experience shared across the transcript point to one undeniable pattern:

When private rents dip, Section 8 rentals do not. And when private rents rise, Section 8 rentals often rise faster.

That combination—scarcity and stability—is what investors refer to (quietly, over coffee, like it’s a secret password) as a rent deflation hedge.

Watch Or Listen To The Selling Greenville Podcast

Subscribe to the Selling Greenville podcast for real-time insights, bold perspectives, and unfiltered takes on the Upstate housing scene. Whether you’re buying, selling, investing, or simply keeping an eye on the market, this is where Greenville stays informed.

Bottom Line

The transcript makes one takeaway unmistakable: the fears investors have about Section 8 rentals are almost always rooted in myth, not reality. The program comes with quirks—inspections, guidelines, screening—but it also delivers something rare in real estate: predictable rent in an unpredictable world.

In a market where private rents can stall or slip, Section 8 rentals keep rising. And for investors aiming to diversify, manage risk, or protect cash flow, that stability can be the difference between uncertainty and confidence during shifting cycles.

Ien Araneta

Journal & Podcast Editor | Selling Greenville